War Horse (2011)

Tom Hiddleston, Geoff Bell, Joey, Jeremy Irvine, and Peter Mullan

After a rather lengthy hiatus, the Movies for Lunch Guys are back! Thanks to Dan for switching offices this blog has suffered greatly, and for that we make no apologies but merely set a new goal for reviewing two movies per month. For our return we watched War Horse, directed by Steven Spielberg. It is rated PG-13 for sequences of war violence. It was nominated for 6 Academy Awards including Best Picture.

Dan -
I have never tried to hide the fact that I love Steven Spielberg movies. I think I’ve seen almost every one of them. And hearing that he was making a movie like this, it should go without saying that I was excited to see it. I had no idea what the story of this movie was since the preview only seemed to show a horse running in various locations during World War I. What I did know was that the play War Horse won 5 Tony Awards last year, including best play, and I thought the movie was an adaptation of the play. I have since learned that both the play and the movie are based on a book. So with an award-winning play already adapted and a supremely talented director set to take the reins, I had very high hopes for War Horse.

This is the story of a remarkably strong and smart thoroughbred horse named Joey who is purchased (unwisely it first seems) to work on a farm in Northern England just prior to World War I. After the Great War begins, the horse is sold to the British infantry, and then changes hands/owners several more times throughout the movie. Meanwhile the boy who trained him, Albert, joins the army and longs to be reunited with Joey.

I am not an animal person. I've never had a pet, and between my wife and I we are allergic to just about every domesticated animal. That being said, the best thing this movie has going for it is Joey and, surprisingly, I found myself emotionally attached to him. I was rooting for him. Each time Joey changes owners is practically an emotional travesty - he is sold to the British Army by Albert’s father in order for them to keep their farm and is subsequently captured by the Germans. He is then discovered by a young French girl and is captured again by the Germans when they march through her farmland, and then ultimately escapes from the grueling clutches of the German army to what would seem almost a worse fate. Simply stated: Joey is put through the ringer, and so was I as I watched this horse endure trial after trial.

If I had one complaint about this movie it is that it feels, for lack of a better word, stagy at times. Not to the point of excess, but rather in the feel of it. For example, the lighting in the first half hour of the movie seemed phony and didn’t look natural at all. There is also a scene toward the end of the movie where a German soldier and a British soldier meet in No Man’s Land and carry on a rather polite conversation. This unlikely situation almost took me out of the movie if it wasn't for the scenes with Joey leading up to it that completely invested me emotionally in the outcome. But it serves the plot and artistic license must be taken (after all, it’s only a movie).

I give this movie 4 out of 5 stars. I wanted to love it more than I actually did, so there was a slight letdown. It took a while to get into it, but as soon as the war started I was hooked. This is a good movie and is in my top ten for the year 2011, but I was expecting and hoping for more.

Nerd Note: This is the second movie released in 2011 (the other is The Adventures of Tintin) that composer John Williams wrote the music for with director Steven Spielberg and the 25^th in total that the two have worked on together. Williams was nominated for an Oscar for the music for both War Horse and Tintin, raising his total Oscar nominations to 47! He is second only to Walt Disney who has 59 nominations. The next closest living nominee: Woody Allen with 23.

Mark-
War Horse tells the story of an amazing horse named Joey.  The film tells the story of Joey’s interactions with a number of individuals during a few months preceding World War I, and following through the duration of the war.  Joey’s journey begins when Ted Narracott ,a lowly farmer, sees great promise in Joey and purchases him for an above average price at auction.  Ted‘s son Albert shares in the faith of Joey, and takes it upon himself to train Joey into the horse that lives up to, and exceeds, expectations.  Due to unfortunate circumstances, Joey is forced into the war, with the hope and promise that Joey will be well taken care of, and returned to Albert when the war is over.  The events of the war bring Joey into contact with a variety of individuals, finding promise in the eyes of the English, German, and French.

Luck, for lack of any better term to use, is a prevalent theme throughout this film.  Unfortunately not all of the luck is good.  From the very beginning it could be argued that Joey had good luck in being bought by the Narracott‘s, but the Narracott‘s dire circumstances could also be termed as the bad luck that forced Joey into the war.  Throughout the war it could be termed good luck for Joey that in each of his interactions, he comes into contact with individuals who continue to see promise and respect in Joey.  The unfortunate bad luck in these circumstances is that many of these new interactions come about because of the demise of the previous interactor(s).

A clearly conveyed message of this film is that of support, and that each of the characters that came into contact with Joey were made better for it; not only better, but Joey was able to bring out the best in them.  Joey is also able to learn from each of the characters that care for him, and thus the support and kindness is shown between each of the characters and Joey.

The one thing I found somewhat interesting prior to viewing the film, is the notion that Steven Spielberg made a big budget film with virtually no star actors or actresses.  Granted there are plenty of distinguished supporting actors in the cast, but the absence of any big names actually helps the film more than any other detail in my opinion.  By having lesser known stars, and primarily only minor characters; the film is able to show and maintain that the major focus and star of the film is Joey.

Overall I enjoyed this film, to the extent that I would likely put in my top 10 movies for 2011, but not so much that it would make it in my top 5.  There are unfortunately a few parts that are slow, but there are also extremely compelling and gripping moments (my favorite being the meeting of the English and German soldiers between enemy lines).  4 *’s out of 5.  

My Random Thought For War Horse: My random thought for this film is really more of a random bit of trivia, courtesy of imdb.com.  There were a total of 14 horses that portrayed Joey in this film with the main horse, Finder, also having starred as Seabiscuit in its film.

Top 10 Sports Films

We here at Movies For Lunch are proud to present another installment of the top ten list. Ever since our review of Coach Carter, our minds have been plagued by the thought of what would be considered the best sports movie. Since there are so many to choose from that are great in different ways we came up with a list. We came up with these movies individually which may explain why some movies are on both of our lists. So here are the top ten sports movies.

Dan - I’m not quite sure where to begin this list. I will list them alphabetically since it seems unfair to compare movies that are so different. I admit that I have not seen what some would consider great and classic like Raging Bull, Bull Durham, or Eight Men Out. I like all of these movies and it is fair to say that I found all of them to be uplifting and inspirational. Some of them are Oscar winners (The Fighter, Million Dollar Baby), and others clearly are not (Happy Gilmore). One could argue that many of these movies may not even be about sports, but use sports as a theme to simply tell a great story (see Field of Dreams). So without further ado, The Lists:


 Cinderella Man (2005) - Russell Crowe and Ron Howard had previously collaborated with the Oscar-winning A Beautiful Mind, and re-teamed here for the based on a true story of boxer Jim Braddock. This is a fantastic movie about a broken man (at times literally) who lived during the Great Depression and was struggling to make enough money just to feed his family, much like the rest of the country during that period. There are some really cool boxing scenes with several point of view shots on the receiving end of a few punches which made it seem like I was participating in the ring instead of just watching. The story itself is ultimately so triumphant that I’m going out on a limb here and calling it not only the best movie of 2005, but the best boxing movie I’ve seen.


 Field of Dreams (1989) - Have you ever noticed that some of the best sports movies aren’t so much about sports? There is hardly any baseball in this movie and the focus is not on an individual player or a team’s quest to win the championship. It is the story about a man’s (Kevin Costner) discovery he makes about himself before he understands why he is compelled to do such strange things as make a baseball diamond in the middle of his corn crop ("If you build it, he will come). The whole movie leads up to the realization of his own father’s regrets of the relationship (or lack thereof) with his son. And this one line: "Hey, dad? You wanna have a catch?" This line alone is responsible for making many a grown man cry (including me). Every time I hear this I think of the times when I was a kid and used to play catch with my old man. Hopefully you do too.


 The Fighter (2010) - I would have never guessed that this scrappy movie about a scrappy boxer would almost be the best boxing movie I’ve ever seen. It sucked me in right from the start (maybe it was the catchy soundtrack). This is another movie where the boxing is only a part of the greatness of it. The rest lies in the compelling portrayal of the family relationship between Mark Wahlberg, Christian Bale, and Melissa Leo, the latter two winning Oscars for their work here. Bale and Wahlberg play boxing brothers with Leo is their mother/manager. While the boxing is exciting in and of itself, it is the family dynamic that is the real meat of the movie. Leo is the ultimate manipulator and Bale is so convincing as a crack addict that I believed him to be this actual person and not an actor. Just watch it. You will be surprised how slyly you are drawn into their world. But be warned that there is a fair amount of language (especially the F-bomb).


 Happy Gilmore (1995) - The funniest sports movie on the list by far. The ridiculous plot follows a hockey player (who doesn’t know how to skate!) entering the equivalent of the PGA tour because his slapshot translates well on the golf course. You might recognize Happy’s love interest Virginia from the current TV comedy hit Modern Family as high-strung mom Claire Dunphy. A fact which I did not notice until my wife pointed it out me. Two scenes make me cry from laughing so hard: The scenes with Bob Barker, and the missed putt where Happy launches a profanity-laced tirade that the broadcast TV censors try to edit. This movie is quoted almost as much as Tommy Boy in my circle of friends. Keep a sharp eye for Ben Stiller as a slave-driving retirement home employee. Please, please remember to not take it seriously, and just laugh at how absurd it really is.


 Hoosiers (1986) - This movie is the first movie about basketball that I ever remember seeing and it has yet to topped as far as basketball movies go. I watched it with my dad and brothers when we were kids. Hoosiers to me is the quintessential basketball movie. A new coach with unusual methods shows up and teaches the players fundamentals, physicality, and how to play with confidence. It takes place in a small town in Indiana where most of the players are farm boys without a lot of amazing talent except for one guy, and the movie wisely does not focus on him but keeps it about the team. Gene Hackman as the coach gives a performance that makes you as the viewer want the team to win as much for him as for themselves. And it’s based on a true story. What’s not to love?


 The Karate Kid - I’m talking about the original here, and not the crappy sequels (except for Karate Kid 2) or the modest re-make. Mr. Miyagi and Daniel LaRusso all the way. I used to call myself Daniel-san and attempt the crane kick whenever my friends and I wrestled each other. This story of a kid who is bullied and learns to defend himself is even more relevant today, especially as one hears of teens ending their own lives as a result of bullying. The best way I can think to describe this movie is uplifting. Watch it and be uplifted. There are portions that may seem a little dated, but it certainly doesn’t detract from the message. And Mr. Miyagi was nominated for an Oscar!!


 Million Dollar Baby (2004) - I had no expectations going into this movie. This was the first movie that Clint Eastwood directed that began my understanding and appreciation for how great of a filmmaker and actor he really is. After watching this I went back and re-watched some of his previous movies like Mystic River and Unforgiven. The guy’s an incredible talent on both sides of the camera. Anyway, I had read a few reviews of it and heard it was good, but I was blown away. I don’t know how Eastwood did it, but he took a movie about boxing and made it about so much more. There was a lot of flak about the second half of the movie (which I will not reveal/discuss here), but I realized that this isn’t so much about what decisions are made as it is about the feelings/motivations behind them, or the "why" of it all. And as the relationships between the characters is observed it becomes clear why these people do what they do, like why Hilary Swank wanted to become a boxer in the first place, and why Eastwood didn’t want to manage/coach any more boxers.


 The Natural (1984) - I love how fitting the title of this movie is. Robert Redford stars as Roy Hobbs, who was literally on his way to be "the best there ever was" playing baseball before suffering a horrific setback. The rest of the story is about how he still makes it big. The more I think about it, the more I love how this movie comes together. Everything seems to be going against Redford to keep him from being successful from the owner of the team he plays for betting against his own team to being distracted by Kim Basinger, all the way to his beloved bat breaking when he needed it the most. It’s the journey of this guy that becomes so compelling, almost more than his talent for baseball. And the last scene is a spectacular contrast to the rest of the movie’s pizzazz.


 Remember the Titans (2000) - This movie always strikes me as an important sports movie, if there is such a thing. Denzel Washington is appointed as the head coach of a football team in Virginia that becomes one of the first schools to integrate after the Civil Rights Movement. The resulting racism from both sides makes for a compelling movie on its own, but throw in the egos of young athletes who think they are better than everyone else and you’ve got a movie ripe with conflict to be resolved. I don’t know how much of this "based on a true story" movie is fictionalized, but it was done in such a way that I feel as uplifted as I do when I watch the original Karate Kid. This is an inspiring movie. Watch it and be both uplifted and inspired to never judge people by the color of their skin. And just for fun, look sharp for before-they-were-famous stars Ryan Gosling and Kate Bosworth.


 The Sandlot (1992) - This is the quintessential kid-sports movie about pickup games and having fun. There is nothing spectacular about the plot to get back an autographed baseball signed by Babe Ruth from a giant dog holding it hostage other than seeing all of the ways the kids come up with to retrieve it. I think movies like this are great because they remind me of similar experiences from my own childhood. Not that I ever had anything this exciting happen, but I seem to remember something like it. I loved just getting the chance to go play with my friends every day during the summer. I guess nostalgia is a big reason that I continue to enjoy this movie as an adult as opposed to just when I was a kid.

Mark -
My own criteria in determining this list had as much to do with what films I really enjoy, as compared to films that I think were really well made. In order to make the list for me these films all receive a yes to the question of "If this film is on, am I going to watch it?" I don’t care if it’s on TV or DVD or something else, if I see the film, the chances are that I’m going to watch at least part of it. Having said that, here are my favorite/top sports films in no particular order.

1) The Fighter - Even though Mark Wahlberg plays the main character in this film, Christian Bale easily steals the focus and attention anytime he is on screen. This film reminds me of a terrible accident that you had to look at, but at the same time you simply can’t help but look and be amazed at the horrifying results.

2) Cinderella Man - I have to admit that I am a big fan of Russell Crowe, and thus this movie easily makes my list. I know a lot of people who hate boxing, but have loved this movie simply because of the plot centered around the struggles endured during the great depression.

3) Field Of Dreams - Of all of the films on this list, this is the film that I have watched more times than any other. It got to the point a few years ago where no one could stand to be in the same room as me while I watched this film, simply because I could repeat the entire dialogue. This is one of the few films that is equal to or better than the book in my opinion.

4) Hoosiers - For me this is by far the best basketball film ever made. Dennis Hopper and Gene Hackman both give amazing performances. There have been a lot films that try to depict the same underdog defeating the giant scenario, but none of them do it as well as Hoosiers.

5) Rocky (as the series, minus Rocky V) - You simply can’t talk about sports movies without mentioning the Rocky films. One of the best parts about these films is still the music. I’m glad that Stallone decided to make Rocky Balboa so that the franchise didn’t have to end on the mess that was Rocky V.

6) Caddyshack - My bias again comes out with this selection because I think that Bill Murray is one of, if not the, funniest comedians in film. Murray’s role as Carl the groundskeeper is one of the funniest things I have ever watched. This film amazes me even more after learning how much of the dialogue was improvised by the actors. Harrold Ramis and Bill Murray really made some great movies together.

7) The Sandlot - The characters, and especially their nicknames, are some of my favorites ever. This film really does remind me of what it was like to simply be a kid and get together with friends to play baseball, or any other sport, after school or during the summer. I can still remember my group of friends determining who was which character from this movie. Just for the record I was Smalls, although my favorite character is Squints.

8) Major League - Its impossible for me to watch a baseball and not think of "just a bit outside" anytime a wild pitch is thrown. The revelations of Charlie Sheen actually taking steroids for this film, and Wesley Snipes being incredibly slow only seem to add to the lore of this film in my opinion. Seeing where those two actors are now in their lives what is perhaps even crazier is the notion that these revelations don’t seem shocking at all.

9) Million Dollar Baby - Clint Eastwood deserves all of the praise and recognition for this film. No other actor could have played the role that he did in this film. Hilary Swank was definitely good and deserved her praise as well, but this movie would not have been the same without Eastwood.

10) The Rookie - I figure that this film is one that not many others would pick for their own list, but it is one that I really enjoy. Dennis Quaid plays such an easy character to like that it’s hard not to enjoy this film in my opinion. One of my favorite lines also comes from this film which is, "Sometimes you have to stop doing what you want to do, and start doing what you were meant to do."

Armageddon (1998)

Will Patton, Bruce Willis, Michael Clarke Duncan, Ben Affleck, and Owen Wilson

Here for purely entertaining purposes is our review of Armageddon. It stars Bruce Willis, Billy Bob Thornton, and Ben Affleck, all of whom are responsible for literally saving the world. We were surprised to learn that one of the (many) writers credited for this movie is none other than J.J. Abrams, who went on to create some fantastic entertainment including Alias, Super 8, and the re-booted version of Star Trek. This movie is rated PG-13 for disaster violence, language (including 2 F-Bombs), and some foreplay between Ben Affleck and Liv Tyler.

Dan -
I may get a lot of criticism for this next comment, but I’ll say it anyway: I love Michael Bay movies! I’m not sure if it is his unabashed glorification of all things American, his cool low-angle rotating shots of the heroes, or the fact that he knows how make stuff blow up real good. They are enormously entertaining (except for Bad Boys II which just sucked) and, surprisingly, they stir a sense of emotion in me from time to time. Even a movie like this one.

If I have one complaint about Michael Bay movies, it is that there is never any sense of real time or space in most of his movies. The Transformers movies are the worst offenders (There’s a giant airfield behind the Smithsonian with lots of mothballed aircraft? Seriously?), but this movie is right on their heels. And maybe that is the fault of the people who edit his movies, but he still must share some of the blame. There will be unexplained costume changes by the characters, or the sun will suddenly have set from one scene to the next without any justification of time passing. Just my own personal observances, but hey, these are movies and the beauty of this art form is that a person can create whatever reality they want (like simultaneously launching 2 space shuttles within a mile of each other, and then landing those space shuttles on a moving asteroid).

Enough negativity. This movie is for entertainment and nothing else. You as the viewer must be willing to suspend your disbelief and just enjoy the ride, so don’t think too hard about this movie unless you just want to mock it. That being said, I like this movie. It is pure escapist fun. The plot is simple enough: A giant asteroid is headed for Earth and unless it is stopped it will impact and kill the entire planet. NASA seeks the expertise of Bruce Willis’ oil-drilling roughneck crew in order to implant a nuclear bomb in the middle of the asteroid.

I think that many filmmakers, including Bay, take great joy in thinking up ways to destroy the planet. I secretly wonder if Michael Bay and Roland Emmerich (of Independence Day and 2012 fame) were best friends as children since their movies seem to be the most detrimental to Earth. In this movie we see Paris obliterated and New York damaged severely by an array of asteroids (including a shot of the World Trade Center on fire with a hole in it, which almost gave me chills when I saw it).

I give this movie 4 out of 5 stars. It’s strictly a fun movie that you should not be concerned about taking seriously.

Nerd Note: Have you ever noticed just how many movies with similar plots are released, and often in the same year? I submit the following for example: Deep Impact and Armageddon in 1998, Antz and A Bug’s Life also in 1998, Capote and Infamous in 2005, Tombstone and Wyatt Earp in 1994, Mission to Mars and Red Planet in 2000, Dante’s Peak and Volcano in 1997, and Killers and Knight and Day in 2010 to name a few. One would think movie studios checked around before green-lighting some of their projects. I’m just sayin’...

Mark -
Surprisingly this was actually the first time that I have seen this film, and I really don’t feel like I missed out on waiting this long to see it. I really thought that I would enjoy this film since I really like many of the actors in the film, but this film is a classic example of how a bad script can’t be saved by good actors. I understand that this film is supposed to be enjoyed mostly for its special effects and the actors themselves, but the action-comedy approach to this film ends up creating huge problems for the plot, leaving this movie to be nothing but a head shaking joke.

The plot of this film centers around the idea that a meteor the size of Texas is headed towards Earth, and if it isn’t stopped then it will destroy everything and everyone. In order to save the world, it is decided that a group of misfit oil drillers will fly out into space, land on the meteor, and drill into the core of the meteor. Once the drillers have reached a certain depth, a nuclear weapon will be placed in the hole and detonated; theoretically splitting the meteor in such a way that no debris will hit the Earth.

So here’s my major problem with this film: Much to my displeasure every little event in this film becomes life or death. I sat watching this film thinking that I was watching the film 2012 all over again, and that anyone who survives just barely survives, yet the reasoning they use to obtain survival is absolutely ridiculous. For a film with so many characters that are supposed to be very intelligent, these so called intellects came up with some of the stupidest possible solutions or ideas when confronted with problems. Although it is quite obvious from the beginning that time is going to play a major factor in the plot, this film shows absolutely no sense of real time being used, and in my opinion shows one of the dumbest uses of effectively using time to accomplish the desired outcome.

Somehow this film helped relaunch the career of Bruce Willis, and helped to launch the careers of Michael Clarke Duncan and Owen Wilson which I am very grateful for. How they accomplished this I’m uncertain, but I guess any exposure is sometimes better than none. The funny parts of this movie were definitely the most enjoyable for me, but it still couldn’t really due much to save this film. 2 *’s out of 5

My Random Thought For Armageddon: I understand that Michael Bay probably isn’t going for realism in his films, but I unfortunately found Bay’s Transformer films to be just as, if not more realistic than this film.

Coach Carter (2005)

Samuel L. Jackson as Coach Ken Carter

We decided to go for the cliche inspirational sports movie this time around. Coach Carter is rated PG-13 for violence, language, teen partying (aka underage drinking), and some drug material (one of the characters is a dealer on the side).

Dan -
I am a such a sucker for movies that are supposed to inspire people. What can I say? I like being inspired and seeing other people make changes that will affect the rest of their lives. Whether it is fictional or based on a true story, I get pulled in almost every time and become personally involved with the triumphs and failures of the characters. And doesn't everyone love an underdog story?

Have you ever noticed that many of the greatest sports movies have a lot to do with a great coach? This movie fills half of those requirements in that it has a great coach, and Samuel L. Jackson was really good as the coach in this. His intensity along with his propensity for yelling his dialogue is actually appropriate for this movie. I really bought into him as a tough coach who would have such high expectations. And he can be classy at the same time he is yelling. If ever there was a dude who epitomized the term BMF, it's this guy.

For anyone who actually considers watching the movies reviewed on this blog, this really is a compelling story. A coach who puts education before basketball is almost revolutionary. Suspending the games because the players weren't doing well enough in class even though they were undefeated is unprecedented. I know this is Hollywood-ized, but I feel it is almost an important sports movie.

Is this movie as good as Hoosiers or Glory Road? No. But it was a lot better than I thought it was going to be. I thought it was good enough for repeat viewing, so I bought it (albeit used). I liked that it seemed grounded in reality. When it came time for the final game, I really didn't know who was going to win. The editing is highly stylized and the soundtrack is filled with hip-hop music (which I don't necessarily care for), and there are some really distracting subplots. Take for example one of the stars of the team, Rob Brown, has gotten his girlfriend pregnant and is having second thoughts about having a baby. I think the point was to ground the movie in reality, but it had nothing to do with the rest of the movie. Sticking with basketball and the classroom would have really helped this movie along.

I give this movie 3½ out of 5 stars. Samuel L. Jackson and his methods make this movie more than I thought it would be.

The real Coach Ken Carter

Mark -
I feel like this movie has been made so many times, and this film is just another variation of something that has previously been done. I think it’s great that so many individuals have been able to overcome difficult situations, but just because one or two films have been successful with such stories doesn’t mean that all of the other studious should try to have the same success with their own film.

The specifics of the plot of this film are centered around the Richmond (CA) High School Oilers basketball team, a low income/high crime neighborhood, whose long-time coach is ready to retire, and hoping the school’s previous biggest star will agree to take the position over. Ken Carter (Samuel L. Jackson) agrees to coach the team, and immediately makes his presence known by having all players who wish to be on the basketball team sign a contract, stating that they will maintain a minimum 2.3 GPA, dress up on game days, and be respectful towards others. Through Carter’s hard work/my way approach he is able to transform a basketball team that had 4 wins the previous year into a team that would win every regular season game it played in his first season.

The most redeeming quality of this film for me is that there is a lot of emphasis placed on, and given to, the importance of education and its need for getting the students further in life. During a pivotal point in the film, in which the educational requirements and standards of Coach Carter are being challenged, I especially appreciated a statement made by Coach Carter where he is trying to stress the importance of accountability, a trait he feels is lacking or overlooked among professional athletes.

Finally I feel that this film was targeted too much at a specific type of audience, as is the case with most films made by MTV films. The environmental aspects of this film further accentuated by rap and hip hop music, considerable amounts of slang, and stereotypical behaviors. 3 *’s out of 5

My Random Thought For Coach Carter: Here’s a major problem I have with this movie trying to tie a past event into current events. The movie is about the 1999 Richmond team, but they make references to the character Ty Crane being the next Lebron James. That’s great but Lebron James was just entering high school at that time and was nothing of a star yet. If the writers decided to try and put things in a current context, as in the 2005 time frame which the movie was released, then the problem comes when they discuss Crane’s shoe-in to be the next number 1 pick in the NBA draft. Someone failed to do their research showing that the collective bargaining agreement which was entered for the 2006 NBA draft required all eligible players to be at least 19 years old at the start of the draft year. Sorry to whoever was trying to be clever, but clearly you were just trying to combine too many things and ended up with an inaccuracy instead.

Song Of The South (1946)

James Baskett as Uncle Remus telling stories to the children.

We now present a review of Song of the South. We broke into the Disney Vault and found this unforgotten-but-hard-to-come-by film. It is not rated, but would probably be rated G as there is no foul language and the violence is in cartoon form and done for laughs.

Mark -
First things first... no we can’t tell you how we were able to get a copy of this film. I still don’t understand the debate of what makes this film so prejudicial, but I’m certainly glad that I have had the opportunity to view a masterpiece which so few are able to enjoy. If anything I would say that the camaraderie and friendship of the different characters should be commended for their interactions, especially considering this film takes place in the South long before the civil rights movements took place. Having said such, I understand that the complete version of this film has never been released in the United States, and it makes me wonder what parts have been cut out, which may or may not change my opinion.

The storyline of this film deals with Johnny who has just moved to his grandmother’s plantation with his mother, while his father returns to Atlanta to continue his job responsibilities. While Johnny is less than thrilled to have his family broken up, he soon makes new friends with two children on the plantation, Toby and Ginny, and is introduced to the renowned story teller Uncle Remus. The tales of Br’er Rabbit, Br’er Fox, and Br’er Bear are told, bringing to life some of the most vibrant and fun characters in any of Disney’s films.

The animation and music in this film are true gems. It was awarded an academy award for best music and original song for Zip A Dee Doo Dah. In the same year, James Baskett, who plays Uncle Remus and the voice of Br’er Fox, was awarded an honorary academy award for his portrayal of Uncle Remus, making his the first African-American to receive an academy award. Sadly Baskett passed away 4 months after receiving such reward, he was only 44.

If you are able to get as lucky as we were, and are able to view this film, I would certainly encourage anyone to do so. I hope that someday Disney will release this film again, as it deserves to be enjoyed by anyone who chooses to do so. To anyone whom this film may have offended I am sorry, but as was Walt Disney’s motto in life to "keep moving forward", I believe that Disney had a hope for segregation and racism to subside. As a last note it is somewhat ironic to think that the African-American stars of this film were not allowed to attend its premiere in Atlanta, again due to the segregation laws at that time. 4 ½ *’s out of 5.

My Random Thought For Song of the South: I am so happy that Disney came up with the splash mountain ride at their theme parks, allowing all who go on the ride the opportunity to enjoy the music and characters of Song of the South. I can’t help but wonder how many people truly understand the background for that ride though.

Dan -
I'm sure some of you did a double take when you saw the title of this blog post. I nearly did one myself when I found out we would be watching it. I seem to remember parts of this movie from when I was really little as I think we had a copy of a copy of a VHS tape, but it only had the animated parts. I did not remember any important details, and was only familiar with the Zip-A-Dee-Doo-Dah song that I had heard many times. It was something about a fox, a rabbit, and a fake animal made out of tar. And for anyone who thinks that Who Framed Roger Rabbit? is the first movie to blend animation with live action (which included me up until this point), this movie exists to prove you wrong. And Disney did it more than 40 years before Roger Rabbit!

Honestly, I was a little underwhelmed with this movie. I loved the animated sequences more than the live action ones, and the songs are really catchy and I was humming a few of them throughout the rest of the day. The live action stuff took a lot more time to get in to than the animation. It wasn't until Uncle Remus started telling his morality tales about Br'er Rabbit to the kids that I got sucked in. Uncle Remus really is the heart and soul of the movie and makes you care about what happens with each of the characters. He is warm, kind, compassionate, and it doesn't hurt that he's good with the kids.

So on to the controversy. Mark talked about it a little already, so I hope this doesn't sound repetitive. Just to be clear I am a white male, so my perspective is exactly that and I could never understand all of the racist undertones throughout the movie. This movie appears to take place after the abolition of slavery. I am no historian, but for a movie that takes place in the South after the Civil War everyone sure seemed to get along much better than they likely did in real life. Johnny's mom is the one who is the horrible person with her treatment of Uncle Remus. The white family lives in the fancy house on the plantation while in stark contrast Uncle Remus and the other black characters live in poor accommodations. The movie just glosses over everything by making it look like everyone is happy exactly the way things are. It's a large fault that is hard to overlook with today's standards and sensibilities.

Now to discuss other things. I don't know why I found the dynamic of the three animated characters so appealing. Maybe it's because Br'er Bear is portrayed as a big dumb oaf. His voice just made me laugh. And so did hearing the motormouthed Br'er Fox try to explain logic to Br'er Bear about how Br'er Rabbit is trying to fool them both all the time. They just struck me as funny, as if they were all brothers who don't know how to get along with each other and get manipulated and fooled constantly. Br'er Rabbit reminded me a bit of Bugs Bunny and how he always had to use his wits to get out of any trouble. I also grew up watching Looney Toons as well as the old Disney animation when I was a kid, and this took me right back to those memories.

I give this movie 4 out of 5 stars. The animation is fun, and the songs are delightful and catchy.